The Game Show Forum > The Big Board

GSs played only by celebrities

<< < (2/3) > >>

Little Big Brother:
I'd argue that the G-T panel shows (TTTT, IGAS, WML, etc) had the celebrities doing more playing than any of the contestants the show had.

Matt Ottinger:
[quote name=\'Little Big Brother\' date=\'Dec 17 2003, 11:57 PM\'] I'd argue that the G-T panel shows (TTTT, IGAS, WML, etc) had the celebrities doing more playing than any of the contestants the show had. [/quote]
 I don't think anyone would disagree with you, but that's not what Jimmy asked.

Little Big Brother:

--- Quote ---
--- Quote ---I'd argue that the G-T panel shows (TTTT, IGAS, WML, etc) had the celebrities doing more playing than any of the contestants the show had.
--- End quote ---
 


I don't think anyone would disagree with you, but that's not what Jimmy asked.
--- End quote ---

:::Narrows his eyes:::  Fine then, I'll rephrase in a more assertive tone.  I'd say that the G-T panel shows, which had the celebrities doing more of the actual playing, would qualify.  Which one had the longest run (combined) and would that be longer than what has already been suggested?

SRIV94:
[quote name=\'Little Big Brother\' date=\'Dec 18 2003, 10:06 AM\'] :::Narrows his eyes:::  Fine then, I'll rephrase in a more assertive tone.  I'd say that the G-T panel shows, which had the celebrities doing more of the actual playing, would qualify.  Which one had the longest run (combined) and would that be longer than what has already been suggested? [/quote]
 WML? and IGAS I'd probably grant you, but I kinda have to draw the line on TTTT.  You could make the argument that the two liars on TTTT were bona fide contestants, whose job it was to steer the panelists to vote incorrectly for them (and the more successful they were, the more money the team of challengers won).  So you could argue that the civilians were just as integral to the game play as the celebrities.  On WML? and IGAS, a contestant couldn't lie to throw the panelists off the track (although the panelists were pretty good at getting thrown off without that much help), and anything hazy was clarified by the host.

Doug

Matt Ottinger:
[quote name=\'Little Big Brother\' date=\'Dec 18 2003, 12:06 PM\'] Fine then, I'll rephrase in a more assertive tone.  I'd say that the G-T panel shows, which had the celebrities doing more of the actual playing, would qualify. [/quote]
 Well, as long as we're being all assertive, let me be more blunt and say you're simply wrong.  The question was very simple: which game played ONLY by celebrities lasted the longest.  Not which game played MOSTLY by celebrities.   I can assure you that Jimmy is very familiar with the G-T panel shows (all of which lasted longer than Pantomime Quiz, BTW).

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page